# Gate Status Tracking

## Phase 0: Survey
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| explorer_survey_1 | teamwork_preview_explorer | DONE (480 points analyzed, 31 obsolete UUIDs isolated, 449 preserved) | handoff.md |
| explorer_survey_2 | teamwork_preview_explorer | DONE (12 files surveyed across 5 domains, 25 rules synthesized) | handoff.md |
| explorer_survey_3 | teamwork_preview_explorer | DONE (Mem0 vector dynamics analyzed, 27 facts cataloged, 8 queries designed) | handoff.md |

Phase 0 Result: **PASS**

## Milestone 1: Selective Cleanup
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| worker_m1 | teamwork_preview_worker | DONE (31 UUIDs deleted, count=449, test suite 5/5 PASSED) | handoff.md |

Milestone 1 Result: **PASS**

## E2E Testing Track
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| test_writer_e2e | teamwork_preview_test_writer | DONE (TEST_INFRA.md, TEST_READY.md, test_mem0_verification.py) | handoff.md |

E2E Testing Track Result: **PASS**

## Milestone 2: Memory Ingestion
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| worker_m2 | teamwork_preview_worker | DONE (27 atomic facts ingested across 5 areas, count=476, test suite 6/6 PASSED) | handoff.md |

Milestone 2 Result: **PASS**

## Milestone 3: Final E2E Verification & Forensic Audit Gate — Iteration 1
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| reviewer_1 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | REQUEST_CHANGES | handoff.md |
| reviewer_2 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | REQUEST_CHANGES | handoff.md |
| challenger_1 | teamwork_preview_challenger | REQUEST_CHANGES | handoff.md |
| challenger_2 | teamwork_preview_challenger | APPROVE | handoff.md |
| auditor_1 | teamwork_preview_auditor | CLEAN | handoff.md |

Gate Result: **FAIL** (reviewer_1, reviewer_2, challenger_1 REQUEST_CHANGES)
- Failure reason: `tests/test_mem0_verification.py` fails 6/8 queries due to:
  1. Un-scoped query collisions with preserved FreeExile records on `"AEC pricing norms"` and `"database precision"`.
  2. False-positive negative assertions in `test_mem0_verification.py` penalizing authentic rule anti-pattern statements ("DOUBLE cho tiền tệ", "scaffolding rỗng").
  3. Brittle Rank-1 check on Q1 failing despite 100% DSCons domain purity.
  4. Discrepancy: `test_mem0_verification.py` was un-scoped while `test_mem0_m2_ingestion.py` used `project="DSCons"`.

## Milestone 3: Final E2E Verification & Forensic Audit Gate — Iteration 2
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source |
|-------|------|---------|--------|
| worker_rem_1 | teamwork_preview_worker | DONE (Re-indexed 27 boosted facts, count 476, synchronized test suites, 24/24 tests passed) | handoff.md |
| reviewer_m3_iter2_1 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | APPROVE (8/8 queries passed, Top-1 scores 0.71-0.86, 24/24 tests passed, 0% contamination) | handoff.md |
| reviewer_m3_iter2_2 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | APPROVE (All 5 core areas verified, mandatory queries passed >=0.71, 0% legacy remnants) | handoff.md |
| challenger_m3_iter2_1 | teamwork_preview_challenger | APPROVE (Collisions eliminated, Top-1 100% DSCons in scoped/unscoped, 34/34 scoped passed) | handoff.md |
| challenger_m3_iter2_2 | teamwork_preview_challenger | APPROVE (449 non-DSCons preserved intact, high-concurrency stress passed 100%, 0 errors) | handoff.md |
| auditor_m3_iter2_1 | teamwork_preview_auditor | CLEAN (Zero cheat/facades, SQLite 476 points validated, 768-dim float vectors verified, all 31 obsolete UUIDs expunged) | handoff.md |

Gate Result: **PASS**
- All 4 pass criteria strictly satisfied:
  1. Build & tests pass: 24/24 tests passed (100.0%, exit code 0).
  2. Every Reviewer verdict is APPROVE: reviewer_m3_iter2_1 (APPROVE), reviewer_m3_iter2_2 (APPROVE).
  3. Every Challenger confirms correctness: challenger_m3_iter2_1 (APPROVE), challenger_m3_iter2_2 (APPROVE).
  4. Forensic Auditor verdict is CLEAN: auditor_m3_iter2_1 (CLEAN).