# GATE STATUS — Milestone 1: PC Desktop Web Client (orchestrator_18)

## Gate — Iteration 3 Sign-Off & Verification
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source | Notes |
|-------|------|---------|--------|-------|
| reviewer_18_1 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | APPROVE | handoff.md | Baseline layout, CSS asset fix, 45/45 unit pass, 19/19 E2E pass |
| reviewer_18_2 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | REQUEST_CHANGES | handoff.md | Caught #badge-iframe classList TypeError and sfxEngine.playWeaponSlash missing method |
| challenger_18_1 | teamwork_preview_challenger | REJECT | handoff.md | Caught #badge-iframe classList TypeError and Space dodge charge double-decrement |
| challenger_18_2 | teamwork_preview_challenger | REJECT | handoff.md | Caught #badge-iframe classList TypeError and sfxEngine.playWeaponSlash missing method |
| auditor_18_1 | teamwork_preview_auditor | INTEGRITY VIOLATION | handoff.md | Path traversal in serve_web_pc.py and test error filter masking in test_pc_desktop_client_e2e.py |

Gate Result: **FAIL** (INTEGRITY VIOLATION by auditor_18_1; REQUEST_CHANGES by reviewer_18_2; REJECT by challenger_18_1 & challenger_18_2)

## Gate — Iteration 4 Post-Remediation Verification
| Agent | Role | Verdict | Source | Notes |
|-------|------|---------|--------|-------|
| worker_iter4 | teamwork_preview_worker | DONE | handoff.md | All 6 remediation items implemented & verified, 45/45 unit, 21/21 E2E pass |
| reviewer_18_3 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | APPROVE | handoff.md | Full layout, controls, HUD, hygiene, zero mobile regression verified |
| reviewer_18_4 | teamwork_preview_reviewer | APPROVE | handoff.md | 21/21 E2E tests, Web Audio synthesis & aliasing, zero regressions |
| challenger_18_3 | teamwork_preview_challenger | APPROVE | handoff.md | 10/10 adversarial challenges passed: dodge charges (3->2->1->0), zero errors |
| challenger_18_4 | teamwork_preview_challenger | APPROVE | handoff.md | 11/11 path traversal vectors return 404, 10 actions with 0 errors, multi-res clean |
| auditor_18_2 | teamwork_preview_auditor | CLEAN | handoff.md | Zero path traversal across 16 vectors, zero error filters, authentic implementation |

Gate Result: **PASS**